Case story

A Farm Tractor, a Loaded Semi, and a Driver Who Should Not Have Been Driving

Truck crashes on rural Oklahoma highways often get treated as simple rear-end collisions. But the real question can be why that driver was behind the wheel at all. Trucking companies have to keep records on every driver's qualifications and health, and those records can matter as much as the crash scene.

What happened

A man was driving a farm tractor on a rural Oklahoma highway when a fully loaded semi-truck hit him from behind at highway speed. He was seriously injured.

What was disputed

The trucking company produced a personnel file for the driver that left out key information. A central question was whether the company knew the driver had a medical condition that disqualified him from driving a commercial truck. The company knew about the condition.

Key evidence

  • The driver's qualification file, which federal rules require carriers to keep.
  • Medical records from outside sources indicating the driver had been medically disqualified months before the crash.
  • Electronic logging device (ELD) records showing a 14-hour driving window.
  • Data downloaded from the truck's engine control module, the truck's "black box."
  • A vocational economist's report on the man's lost ability to work.

What the firm did

Hicks Law Firm represented the injured man. A letter demanding that the company preserve evidence went out within six hours of the firm being hired. The truck's data was downloaded on day three. The driver qualification file was obtained in week four, and the outside medical records in month two.

The outcome

The case resolved for $3,000,000. Result obtained through settlement. The case settled about seven months into the representation.

What injured people can take from this

After a truck crash, a lot of the important evidence belongs to the trucking company: driver files, logs, and the truck's own data. Some of it can be overwritten or thrown out if no one asks for it to be kept. Asking early, and looking past the crash report to the driver's history, can change what a case is about.

Learn more about commercial truck accidents, negligent hiring by trucking companies, truck accident investigation, truck driver fatigue, and catastrophic injury, or see our truck crash results.

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case is different.

*Disclaimer: The results listed above are not a guarantee of future outcomes. Every case is unique and must be evaluated on its own merits. Some amounts represent the total settlement for all parties. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.