Case story
A Jail Death, Missed Checks, and a $2 Million Jury Verdict
Jury verdict.
When someone dies in jail after asking for help, families are often told nothing could have been done. Jail logs, medical records, and the testimony of people who were there can tell a different story. This is how one Oklahoma County family's case went from a jail cell to a federal jury.
What happened
Gregory Davis was arrested in August 2021 and held at the Oklahoma County jail [KFOR]. About nine days later, he died of a perforated duodenal ulcer [KFOR]. A medical assessment for him was never completed [FOX25]. An internal investigation found that staff skipped five of the six required 30-minute cell checks before he was found unresponsive.
What was disputed
His family's case was filed in Oklahoma County District Court as CJ-2023-1421 [OSCN] and was later moved to federal court in the Western District of Oklahoma in September 2023 [OSCN]. The case, Simms v. Board of County Commissioners for Oklahoma County, et al., was brought against the county commissioners and others [OSCN]. Claims against two individual defendants, the former jail administrator and a jail counselor, also went to the jury [KFOR]. The Oklahoma County Criminal Justice Authority, which runs the jail, defended the case and issued a statement after the verdict [KFOR].
Key evidence
At trial, a gastroenterologist testified that the ulcer likely perforated 12 to 48 hours before Mr. Davis died [FOX25]. An inmate housed on the same floor testified that Mr. Davis begged for a nurse for days [FOX25]. Cell-check logs and jail medical records were part of the evidence at trial.
What the firm did
Jason Hicks entered an appearance for the family's representative, Kizzie Simms, in the state court case in March 2023 [OSCN]. Hicks Law Firm represented the family as the case moved through federal court to trial.
The outcome
A unanimous federal jury awarded $2 million against the Oklahoma County Criminal Justice Authority [FOX25]. The verdict was returned on April 17, 2026. The jurors found the Authority's staff deliberately indifferent to his serious medical needs. The jury did not find the former administrator or the counselor responsible [KFOR].
What families can take from this
If someone you love was hurt or died in custody, the records that matter most, like cell-check logs, video, and medical requests, are held by the jail. Some may be kept only for a limited time. Getting them requested early can make a real difference.
Learn more about jail death claims, missed cell checks, deliberate indifference, jail medical neglect, and claims against jail operators (Monell liability), or see our civil rights results.
Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case is different.
Sources
- [OSCN] Oklahoma County District Court docket, CJ-2023-1421: https://www.oscn.net/dockets/GetCaseInformation.aspx?db=oklahoma&number=CJ-2023-1421
- [KFOR] "Oklahoma County jail faces $2M verdict in inmate death suit" (April 21, 2026): https://kfor.com/news/local/oklahoma-county-jail-faces-2m-verdict-in-inmate-death-suit/
- [FOX25] "Jury awards family of Oklahoma County inmate $2 million": https://okcfox.com/news/local/jury-awards-family-of-oklahoma-county-inmate-2-million
*Disclaimer: The results listed above are not a guarantee of future outcomes. Every case is unique and must be evaluated on its own merits. Some amounts represent the total settlement for all parties. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.